"[P]ath-breaking..."--Sheldon Kirshner, The Times of Israel
"Cohen breaks new ground in her analysis of the Sephardi communities of Salonica, Istanbul, and Izmir, and of the complex and changing forces that tested their allegiance to imperial citizenship and nationality (Ottomanism). She challenges the long-held master narrative that Ottomanism was an abstract ideology that managed to gain a foothold only among the Ottoman elite...The book is engaging, accessible, and an important contribution to late Ottoman history."--Karen M. Kern, International Journal of Middle Eastern Studies
"An excellently researched book, very well argued and written in a gripping manner. Cohen has provided a valuable resource not only for academics and students of the nineteenth-century Middle East but also for those interested more generally in the history of minorities as well as in the emergence of nationalist discourses."--Stefano Taglia, English Historical Review
"An original contribution to scholarly writing on the history of Ottoman Jews, to the study of imperial citizenship, and to the literature on the passage of the Ottoman Empire to modernity."--Avi Rubin, Association for Jewish Studies Review
"Draws the reader in through its engaging style and pithy, psychologically incisive analyses The book offers a far more nuanced and complex picture of Ottoman Sephardim than we have been used to seeing."--Lital Levy, Journal of Levantine Studies
"Eloquently written Cohen's well-researched book demonstrates that the concept of citizenship does not necessarily belong to nation-states In the Ottoman context, the book proves that the concept was an important subject of negotiation between imperial administration, local authorities, intellectuals, and the public."--Kerem Tinaz, Nationalities Papers
"Becoming Ottomans is a very important contribution not only to the historiography of Ottoman Jews but also to nineteenth-century social and cultural history. The book--through its emphasis on civic agency rather than on state policy, on provinces rather than on the capital, and on a 'view from below' that looks up from streets, fairs, and local celebrations rather than on official discourses--is extremely useful to every scholar interested in the dynamics of nineteenth-century Ottoman society in general and in the history of Ottoman Jews in particular. It provides a basis for further debates on the ever-contested history of Christians and Jews in the Ottoman Empire."--Yasar T. Cora, H-Nationalism
"Cohen's research for Becoming Ottomans gives the reader a compelling look at life for Ottoman Jews in the modern period. The earlier 'myth' of Jewish-Ottoman symbiosis is dispelled in this book, replaced instead with real-world case studies that show the variety of experiences of Ottoman Jews."--H-Net
"With Becoming Ottomans, Julia Phillips Cohen breaks new ground in her analysis of the Sephardi communities of Salonica, Istanbul, and Izmir, and of the complex and changing forces that tested their allegiance to imperial citizenship and nationality (Ottomanism). She challenges the long-held master narrative that Ottomanism was an abstract ideology that managed to gain a foothold only among the Ottoman elite....If Becoming Ottomans was only an examination of the Sephardi response to Ottoman citizenship and the imperial national project, it would be a tremendous contribution to the field. But the book touches on many other subjects under debate among Ottoman historians....The book is engaging, accessible, and an important contribution to late Ottoman history."--Karen M. Kern, International Journal of Middle Eastern Studies
"Thoroughly researched and documented...Becoming Ottomans is a major contribution to the study of the Jewish communities during the late Ottoman period and it provides scholars of other Ottoman non-Muslim communities with excellent grounding with which to analyze similar developments among the larger Ottoman Armenian and Greek communities."--Eyal Ginio, Middle East Journal
"In this engaging book, Julia Philips Cohen reconstructs the process by which Ottoman Sephardic Jews learned the language of patriotism in the course of the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, as part of a broader process of the emergence of a discourse of Ottoman imperial citizenship that affected Ottoman society in its entirety....Becoming Ottomans should be commended for its original and sophisticated treatment of the 'special relationship' narrative on the basis of late nineteenth- and early twentieth-century experiences....An original contribution to scholarly writing on the history of Ottoman Jews, to the study of imperial citizenship, and to the literature on the passage of the Ottoman Empire to modernity."--Avi Rubin, Association for Jewish Studies Review
"Cohen's portrayal of Jewish Ottomanism is rich in nuance. We learn about the official discourse of Ottoman patriotism but also about dissenting voices and resistance; we learn about the complex negotiation of imperial citizenship in competition with other ethno-religious groups, such as the Armenians or the Greeks; and we get a sense of the many forms that Jewish Ottomanism could take in an increasingly politicized Jewish millet....Becoming Ottomans represents an important intervention that allows not only a better understanding of the history of the Sephardic Jews in the Ottoman Empire, but of the multifaceted nature of the Jewish encounter with modernity more generally....Cohen's book is as much a contribution to modern Jewish history as it is to the history of the Ottoman Empire."--Matthias B. Lehmann, Sefarad
"Cohen has produced an insightful study on the embrace of Ottoman citizenship by the Sephardic community....Highly recommended."--CHOICE
"It contributes significantly to our appreciation of the complex texture of a long-gone society."--Journal of Modern History"
"Becoming Ottomans is a remarkable account of the means Sephardi Jews developed to represent themselves as loyal Ottomans and to transform themselves into a model community during the last century of the empire. Original and marvelously written, the book reveals the complexities and the setbacks, as well as the successes, of this effort."--Olga Borovaya, author of Modern Ladino Culture
"Based in nineteenth-century Salonica, Istanbul, and Izmir, Julia Phillips Cohen's book tells the story of how Jews were swept up in the Ottoman Empire's projects of imperial reform, war, and ethnic rivalries. They also carved out a place for themselves in politics and society, invented traditions commemorating their arrival in the empire 400 years prior, showcased the empire at the Chicago World's Fair, feted the sultan on his royal tour, and mourned the empire's demise after their arrival in New York. Fascinating, thoroughly researched, and engagingly written, Becoming Ottomans will forever change how we understand the Ottoman Empire and its Jews."--Michelle Campos, author of Ottoman Brothers: Muslims, Christians, and Jews in Early Twentieth-Century Palestine
"Becoming Ottomans offers a fresh argument on strategies of imperial belonging, showing how Sephardi Jews put themselves forward as exemplary citizens, a kind of model minority for the late Ottoman Empire. In doing so, it addresses questions about the complexities of co-existence and provides insight on the unique Ottoman realm of inter-confessional relations as much as about the dynamics within the Sephardi Jewish communities of the empire."--Christine Philliou, author of Biography of an Empire: Governing Ottomans in an Age of Revolution
"If Ottoman historians, Middle Eastern historians, and historians of modern Jewry agree on one thing, it is that Ottoman Jews and the Ottoman state enjoyed a 'special relationship' of solicitude on the part of the state and of unalloyed patriotism on the part of the Jews. Julia Phillips Cohen's Becoming Ottomans draws on an impressively multilingual archive to show that this vaunted special relationship was not a pre-political fact but a fairly late political invention created by the late nineteenth century Ottoman Jewish elite. Cohen demonstrates that this political invention demanded constant maintenance through ritual and discursive evocation, and that it was subjected to deepening strain in the last decades of the empire's existence as Jews grappled simultaneously with nationalist secessions and incipient Muslim Turkish counternationalism."--Kenneth Moss, author of Jewish Renaissance in the Russian Revolution
"The book will serve as a wonderful complement to earlier studies of Jewish emancipation and integration in central European lands, especially in France and Germany. It will also prove enormously useful to scholars of Ottoman and Middle Eastern history as well as those interested in the burgeoning field of Muslim-Jewish relations."--Scott Ury, Religious Studies Review
