This is the chief point of difference with comparatism: the comparatist Urmyth is an actual historical entity which is identified as the cause of all derivative myths. Similarly, a psychological archetype, for both Freud and Jung, has a historical referent as well as a "material" existence as a trace or imprint on the mind. Propp's tale, by contrast, is a purely theoretical construct. Not only does it differ from the comparatist's and psychoanalyst's Urform as construction to reality, but it also differs in the dynamic of its relation to all variants: for the comparatists and psychoanalysts all variants derived their meaning and authority from proximity to the Urform, but for the formalists the Urform could only derive meaning and authority from the variants of the tale, all of which were of equal consequence.
·
33 görüntüleme
Yorum yapabilmeniz için giriş yapmanız gerekmektedir.