Free Will Sözleri ve Alıntıları
Free Will sözleri ve alıntılarını, Free Will kitap alıntılarını, Free Will en etkileyici cümleleri ve paragragları 1000Kitap'ta bulabilirsiniz.
Yapmayı seçtiğiniz şeyleri yapabilirsiniz; ama ne yapmayı seçeceğinizi seçemezsiniz.
Her halükârda etkin olarak istediklerimi yapmaya meyilliyim. Ve neyin etkin olacağına karar veremediğim gibi, isteklerimi de önceden belirleyemem. Benim zihni dünyam çok basit bir şekilde bana kozmos tarafından sağlanmıştır. Neden su yerine meyve suyu içmeye karar vermedim? Hiç aklıma gelmedi. Peki yapabileceğim ama aklıma gelmeyen şeyleri yapmakta özgür müyüm? Kesinlikle hayır.
Imagine that a person claims to have no need to eat food of any kind—rather, he can live on light.From time to time, an Indian yogi will make such a boast, much to the merriment of skeptics. Need-less to say, there is no reason to take such claim sseriously, no matter how thin the yogi. However, a compatibilist like Dennett could come to the charlatan’s defense: The man does live onlight—we all do—because when you trace the origin of any food, you arrive at something that depends on photosynthesis. By eating beef, we consume the grass the cow ate, and the grass ate sunlight. So the yogi is no liar after all. But that’s not the ability the yogi was advertising, and his actual claim remains dishonest (or delusional). This is the trouble with compatibilism. It solves the problem of “free will” by ignoring it.
If you pay attention to your inner life, you will see that the emergence of choices, efforts, and intentions is a fundamentally mysterious process.
Even if the human mind were made of soul-stuff, nothing about my argument would change. The unconscious operations of a soul would grant you no more freedom than the unconscious physiology of your brain does.
How can we be “free” as conscious agents if everything that we consciously intend is caused by events in our brain that we do not intend and of which we are entirely unaware? We can’t. To say that “my brain” decided to think or act in aparticular way, whether consciously or not, and that this is the basis for my freedom, is to ignore the very source of our belief in free will: the feel-ing of conscious agency. People feel that they are the authors of their thoughts and actions, and this is the only reason why there seems to be a problem of free will worth talking about.
Without free will, sinners and
criminals would be nothing more than poorly calibrated clockwork, and any conception of justice that emphasized punishing them (rather than deterring, rehabilitating, or merely containing them) would appear utterly incongruous.
You are not in control of your mind because you, as a conscious agent, are only part of your mind, living at the mercy of other parts.You can do what you decide to do—but you cannot decide what you will decide to do. Of course,you can create a framework in which certain decisions are more likely than others—you can, for instance, purge your house of all sweets, making it very unlikely that you will eat dessert later inthe evening—but you cannot know why you were able to submit to such a framework today when you weren’t yesterday
Martin Heisenberg
The biologist Martin Heisenberg has observed that certain processes in the brain, such as the opening and closing of ion channels and the release of synaptic vesicles, occur at random, and cannot therefore be determined by environmental stimuli. Thus, much of our behavior can be considered truly “self-generated”—and therein, he imagines, lies a basis for human freedom. But how do events of this kind justify the feeling of free will? “Self-generated” in this sense means only that certain events originate in the brain.
Clearly, a full account of the causes of human behavior should attenuate our natural response to injustice, at least to some degree.
Compatibilists, however, claim that determinists and libertarians are both confused and that free will is compatible with the truth of determinism.
The physiologist Benjamin Libet famously used EEG to show that activity in the brain’s motor cortex can be detected some 300 milli-seconds before a person feels that he has decided to move. Another lab extended this work usingfunctional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI):Subjects were asked to press one of two buttons while watching a “clock” composed of a random sequence of letters appearing on a screen. They reported which letter was visible at the moment they decided to press one button or the other. The experimenters found two brain regions that contained information about which button subjects would press a full 7 to 10 seconds before the decision was consciously made. More recently, direct recordings from the cortex showed that the activity of merely 256 neurons was sufficient to predict with 80 percent accuracy a person’s decision to move 700 milli seconds before he became aware of it.
Ironically, one of the fears attending our progress in science is that a more complete understanding of ourselves will dehumanize us.
There will always be some delay
between the first neurophysiological events that kindle my next conscious thought and the thought itself.
Yes, you are free to do what you want even now. But where did your desires come from?